My last video on the midterms seemed to rub quite a few of you the wrong way, so let me provide some context. The congressional shift isn’t what’s important here; the impending collapse of America’s two-party structure is why the midterms matter.

Sure, the Democrats made historic gains, but they still lack the numbers to control the agenda. The midterm results show both parties have lost their foundations, and they have two paths forward. Either a new political movement emerges and replaces the current coalitions, or one of the existing parties rebuilds from the ground up.

Transcript

Hey, everybody. Peter Zeihan here. Coming to you from Colorado. A lot of you have written in on the Patreon system saying, hey, are you sure you don’t think that this election really mattered the midterms? Because it was, like, the biggest midterm sweep and the biggest change in personnel in 40 years. Does matter, probably not in the way you’re thinking. 

So step one, why I’m kind of dismissive. Unless you get 60% of the seats in both houses of Congress, you can’t force a vote on a bill. And the Democrats, despite their gains, got that in neither House, so they can’t control the agenda. In addition, unless you get two thirds of the Senate specifically, you can’t force impeachment. I mean, sure, you can have a trial, but you’re not going to convict anyone. So from my point of view, there’s a lot of drama here, and it’s obviously significant politically, but it doesn’t really change the math. Trump didn’t use Congress when he controlled it. Why would he use it now? And in fact, his new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, has made it very clear that he’s going to be ruling by executive order pretty much constantly, which is more or less what he did in the first two years. So no big change.  

How it does matter is different. It has to do with the party structures. We have a first past the post single member district system, which is a way of saying that when you go to the voting box, you vote for one person who will represent your specific geographic area and the neighbors who live in that area. You don’t go and you vote for a party. So there are a lot of countries in the world that have some sort of proportional representation. So if a party gets say one quarter of the votes, they get roughly one quarter of the seats in the Parliament or the Congress. That’s not how the U.S. does it. If you do it that way, if you do proportional representation, the parties tend to be really, really strong. And the members who come off of a list that you know before you vote, if they decide to deviate from the party leadership and the party programs, then they tend to get kicked out of the party altogether. That doesn’t happen in the United States, because we have a first past the post system and you’re voting for a person. Those people choose to then associate with a party, and that party may or may not have a good disciplinary system. Odds are not. So you get a wide coalition of interests. Keep in mind that when you’re in a first past the post system, it’s about getting one more vote than whoever comes in second, and then winner takes all. And that means you’re not after 10%, or 20% or 50% of the vote in order to get into Parliament. You’re after this specific seat and it’s all or nothing. And so to that end, the parties, instead of supporting a somewhat common class set of values that you either vote for or don’t. It tends to control itself through having many, many factions, and you try to throw as wide of a net as possible at as many factions as possible that show up to support you on Election Day so you can get that extra marginal vote. Well, factions, by definition, rise and fall in power based on circumstances, whether it is military issues or security issues or economic issues or technological issues or cultural issues. And from time to time, as these groups rise and fall, sometimes you’ll have enough changes that one of the factions or more will leave the coalition altogether, and maybe factions from the outside will come in. And in times when enough of that happens, the party loses cohesion and the tent falls. And then you have to start over, either with a new force that comes in from the outside, a new coalition, or maybe they’re able to put the tent back up with just different people. In the United States, we’ve done this six times so far. We are currently at the end of what is called the seventh party structure. And I would argue that between the last elections in 2024, in these in 2026, the seventh party structure is now formally over. Why? 

Well, let’s start with the Democrats, because they broke first. Go back 20 years. And at the end of the Bush administration, there was a huge amount of support for ending Republican rule in Congress because of the Iraq war. And we got Barack Obama, which is probably one of the most isolated personalities who has ever been in the White House. He was largely elected outside of the party structures. He ran his own institution. And then when he got in the white House, he refused to meet with pretty much anyone, including his own party stalwarts. So for eight years, the nominal leader of the Democratic Party didn’t lead the Democratic Party, and he sucked all the air out of the room and basically prevented a new generation of leadership from rising. Then after Obama, we had Trump. And once again, the Democrats found themselves defined by what they were not: we’re not Trump. That’s not a party program. And after Trump’s first term, Joe Biden came in back from the wilderness after mourning the loss of his son. And we got a guy from a past generation who really only ruled for two, two and a half years before his mind started to go. And so we had another four years where the Democrats were functionally unable to prepare whatever was next. Biden may have come in saying he was a transitional figure, but then he didn’t do anything to actually transition to whoever was next. And now, once again, we’ve got Trump. And, you know, after four years of Biden, which, you know, weren’t that bad honestly, the Democratic Party, what was left of it was shocked, shocked that Donald Trump came back from the political wilderness after everything he had done, being the most unpopular president in history, having the January 6th insurrection issue, actually being a convicted felon and winning anyway. That tells me that two years ago, the Democratic Party, which had no program and had no leader and had no future, died completely. And that hasn’t changed in the last two years. 

What’s changed in the last two years is Donald Trump has destroyed the Republican Party. When he was in power the first time, he didn’t expect to win. So he basically tapped the Republican Party for all of its brain trust to fill all of the positions. And then it didn’t go very well. So he ended up firing almost all of them to make sure that he would never have that kind of intellectual overshadowing again. When he was out of power, he took over the Republican National Committee, destroyed the recruiting arm so they could never, ever be anyone else who could run as a Republican new, without getting his personal blessing. And he destroyed the policy arm so he would never be in a room with a Republican who knew more than him. He basically dropped the IQ of the room to match whatever he wanted. Well, he then wins, and we’ve had two years of that rule where he’s actively campaigning against Republicans who won’t kowtow to him in every single moment. Even people like Nancy Mace, who probably had 99.9% of votes, were rabidly pro-Trump. 99.9 wasn’t enough. So out she goes. And we’ve now lost Collins and, oh geez, I’m forgetting the names because it’s already been too long. We’ve lost Tillis. We’ve lost Cornyn. Big Republican names, very powerful people. All of them are now gone from Congress. And all that is left of the Republican caucus in Congress are now people who are slavishly loyal to Trump. And if you look at polling, fewer Americans now identify as Republican than in the history of the party. And the history of the party goes back to Lincoln. But of the smaller number, a higher percentage describe themselves as MAGA. So the Republican Party, the institution that supports national security and business growth and fiscal conservatism and law and order, it’s gone. And all the people who championed those tenants in Congress are gone as well. All that’s left is the cult of Trump. 

And so what we saw in elections last week is the rest of the country, especially independents like me, were like, fuck that. And we saw the biggest shift in a midterm vote, I think, in a century. We now have more new people in Congress when they sit down January 20th than we have had it since at least 1992, which was the last time we went through one of these big reshufflings. So the Democrats are gone and the Republicans are gone. And the question is what’s next? Well, there’s a couple of ways that this can go based on past experience. We can get a third party that comes in and challenges the detritus of what’s left for the other two. Maybe it is able to consolidate into a new force, maybe one of the Democratic or Republican parties using the same branding, basically, but with the new factions manages to rise. And whichever of those happens first will probably rule the country without opposition for 5 to 10 years, because there just won’t be any opposition. A good way to think about it, if you look at what the Democrats ran this last time, they didn’t have good candidates, they didn’t have any leadership, they had no programs, they had no coordination, and they really didn’t even have great fundraising. And yet they swept. That’s how gone the Republican Party is. But it also means if anyone else can come up with a credible program, they’ll just walk away with everything. Another option is we can have a charismatic person rise from within the ranks or come in from the outside, and it basically people run on his or her coattails to define whatever’s next. Basically another version of Trump, if you will. 

In the United States, we’ve tried both of these things three times. And when it comes to the third party option, that’s actually where the Democrats and the Republicans came from originally 150 years ago. So there are a lot of options here. All I can tell you for now is that it really doesn’t matter to me who is in Congress, because Congress doesn’t have enough unity in whatever that faction happens to be to force anything to happen. Which means that the executive in this moment, just like in past transition, holds functionally all the power in the country because there’s no one to challenge it. So love Trump or hate him, he is the only game in town for the next two years, unless there’s a break within MAGA to force something like impeachment. Doesn’t matter if his cabinet secretaries get impeached. I mean, some of them should be, but it doesn’t change the balance of power here because Trump is basically ruling alone. And that’s where we’re going to be until a new force arises. I don’t think that’s going to happen in the next two years.

Recommended Posts