A Flawed Trade System in Europe

Photo of a US aircraft carrier on the water

European efforts to build trade systems that exclude the U.S. are inherently flawed.

Without the U.S. Navy securing global trade routes, Europe will be limited in how far its trade network can extend. Given how protectionist the EU is, especially with agriculture, meaningful trade agreements will be difficult to negotiate. And even if they get through all of that, Europe’s slow and complex ratification process is no walk in the park.

The latest agreement with Australia will likely face a similar fate to the Mercosur and Canada deals, which took decades to finalize. Best case, this deal will take full effect around 2040…

Prefer to read the transcript? Click here

Transcript

Hey, everybody. Peter Zeihan here, coming to you from Colorado. This is Pandora, the other cat. She’s a little louder when it’s meal time. Anyway, on the topic of things that are loud and annoying and sometimes take forever to do anything, let’s talk about trade deals with the European Union, because, wow, those are a shit show. So the big news is that in Europe, they’re trying to come up with non U.S alternatives to the international order. 

This faces three really big problems. First of all, there is no international trade without the US Navy. The Europeans absolutely do not have the capacity to project naval power very far past their own front yard. So if they want to trade with Turkey or Russia or North Africa, sure. But anything beyond that, they really do need the security that the US Navy granted. 

So let’s just put that to the side. Number two, the Europeans are aggressively protectionist, particularly when it comes to agriculture and most trade deals that have been negotiated in the last 30 years have found a way to kind of leave that out of the equation. Which is a way of saying that they really haven’t negotiated many trade deals in the last 30 years. 

Which brings us to the track record, the Europeans are so technical and so detail oriented and so emotional about the details. And then there’s a ratification process that we’ll get into here in a minute. That they can’t do anything quickly. So, for example, we now have a trade deal that has been negotiated with the Australians. And that was done in record time less than a year. 

That’s really, really good. But the ratification process is a whole different question. So the deal that was recently ratified, with the Brazilians, the Argentinians, you know, the Mercosur bloc that was negotiated back around the year 2001, and they only now finish it. We had a Canada free trade agreement that was negotiated in the early 20 tens. 

That took 11 years to get through. The issue is, not only does the European Union have to sign on, deliver the treaty. Each of the member governments and has to sign off, and some of those member governments require plebiscites. Some of them require regional legislatures, signing off. In the case of Canada was Belgium was the real sticker. 

And we’re going to have something similar here now for the Australian deal because it’s very heavy on, as you might guess, agriculture. Australia is a massive agricultural producer, an exporter, and they have insisted reasonably that any trade deal that is going to access the raw materials also has to allow access for their trade goods, whether it’s beef or lamb or wheat or whatnot. 

And we already have farmers across the European Union, including the trade associations and of course, the French saying that this deal has no chance of getting ratified. So if in the ideal situation, everyone ultimately lines up and teaser cross crossing eyes or dotted noses are counted and it goes through, we can look forward to the first large scale transfer of Australian goods to the European market in the year 2040. 

I am not going to be doing this long enough for that to matter.

The Strait of Hormuz Remains Open…For Iran

Despite the ongoing conflict in the Persian Gulf, shipping in the Strait of Hormuz remains open…sort of. The Iranians have taken control, requiring ships to get clearance for safe passage.

Basically, Iran has set up a protection racket. They’re earning more from transit fees and oil exports than before the war, and all the Chinese ships carrying drone parts and components heading to Iran remain untouched. Even with the significant U.S. military presence in the region, nothing is being done to disrupt these flows.

Until that stops, Iran’s military operations and economy will continue to grow stronger.

Prefer to read the transcript? Click here

Transcript

Hey all, Peter Zeihan here. Still sick. Coming to you from Colorado. This is Loki. You may have heard him or seen him in videos in the past. Anyway, today I wanted to let you know about a little internal investigation that we’ve been running in the ER on war. 

Specifically, we’ve got questions here on our end, about why shipments are still getting through the Persian Gulf at all. 

Now, international insurance has basically been canceled for all ships in the area. Basically, once somebody starts shooting civilian shipping, all bets are off and the captains are on their own and if the ship takes a hit, oftentimes it’s the captain that is legally or financially vulnerable. If not the shipping company. And there’s no way to file a claim in that circumstance. 

So lots of ships are trapped inside the Gulf, and there’s a couple hundred waiting outside for things to clear, which isn’t going to happen anytime soon. And yet, there are still some ships coming and going, but all of them have gotten clearance from Iran. So under normal circumstances, there’s a six mile navigable channel that’s roughly in the middle of the Strait of Hormuz. 

Most of it is actually in Omani territory. Some of it does go into Iranian territory, and there’s a two mile channel for going one way, a two mile channel for going the other way, and then a two mile gap in the middle. That is not being used by anyone. That’s what’s completely shut down because of the attacks we’ve had so far. 

On the other side of the equation, you’ve got Iran basically processing ships, at the Imam Khomeini port, which is way up in Khuzestan, which is on the northern extreme of the Gulf, actually in the general vicinity of Kharg Island, if you know where that is. So for ships wanting to get passage approval from Iran, they have to sail all the way to the northern end of the port, basically under all the drone and missile attacks that are going back and forth. 

They have to dock at Imam Khomeini port. They have to basically get their papers, pay their bill, which comes out for a large ship to be like $2 million. And then they sail down the Iranian coast as close to the Iranian coast as they can. 

And instead of using that navigable pathway through the middle of the street, they hug the Iranian coast as closely as they can and sail through that way. 

And same for anyone who’s coming in. They have to sail all the way up to Khuzestan to basically get their papers stamped. So what has happened here is a clear example of the United States just being unable to process what’s going on on the front end. 

United States seemed woefully unprepared for anything happening in the Strait of Hormuz, during a war with Iran, which is just beyond ludicrous, because that has been the issue since 1979, and there was no meaningful preparation of all. Second, Iran has managed to set up a basically a protection racket, and cargo is still not just coming to and from Iranian ports, including Chinese, gear that basically is full of drone parts. 

They’re actually able to sail into the Strait of Hormuz all the way up and into the northern Gulf, not be molested at all. Docketed Iranian port, or take on cargo, pay their fees, and then sail all the way back down through the Persian Gulf, through the Strait of Hormuz, and out. And the United States is doing nothing. 

So the idea of that, the Iranian authorities, as they are at the moment, are under pressure is just mind bogglingly stupid because the economy of Iran is largely managed by the IRGC. And we have actually, in these circumstances, seen income for the IRGC go up because the not only are they getting these transit fees, but the core issues of economic smuggling still apply. 

And even though the US military is now more present in this region than it has been at any time in modern history, it is doing nothing to interrupt the commercial flows going to and from Iran, and Iran is able to increase the volumes of its exports to nearly 2 million barrels per day and garner the war surcharge. So they’re earning easily in terms of profits. 

Two and three times what they were earning before the war. And the U.S. military is doing nothing. Now, under normal circumstances, there are analysts at the military and especially at the Department of Energy who would point these things out to their chain of command, and it would go up to the department heads and eventually the president. But President Trump fired all those people last year. 

So it took people like me doing this little project on the side to figure out how everything is flowing. Someone please tell Trump because until this is interrupted in some way too big problems. Number one, the IRGC is giving them more money now than they did before, which reinforces all of the pillars of the Iranian structure that allows it to fight the war and encourages political cohesion. 

Second, they have no problem resourcing parts for missiles, and especially drones from the Chinese, and so they’re able to maintain their current pace of fighting more or less indefinitely. So yeah, someone please pass that along. Maybe it’ll make a difference.

U.S. Ground Troops Coming to Iran

Squad of Soldiers Running Forward and Atacking Enemy During Military Operation in the Desert | Licensed by Envato Elements: https://app.envato.com/search/photos/b369387a-4bc2-43d2-808a-0341aa11dbcc?itemType=photos&term=military+desert&sort=relevance

The U.S. is preparing for a potential ground operation in Iran. Marines from the USS Tripoli and Boxer, as well as elements from the 82nd Airborne, could be looped in. That’s roughly 8,000 troops, which is just a small-scale, fast-response force, but no matter the size, boots on the ground is a scary endeavour.

If Kharg Island is in fact the target, the retaliation from Iran would be massive. This is Iran’s main oil export hub, which means it’s the main revenue source as well; with that gone, Iran would unleash hell. And Kharg Island would be extremely difficult for U.S. forces to defend; they would be under constant threat of drone strikes, and quite exposed.

Another plan would be to use these troops for targeted raids along the Strait of Hormuz, disrupting Iran’s ability to attack shipping.

Prefer to read the transcript? Click here

Transcript

Hey all, Peter Zeihan here coming to you on March 25th from inside the house in Colorado because, false alarm. I’m not getting better and sicker. Anyway, I’m going to talk about, Iran today, specifically what’s going on? Ground troops, which looks like they’re absolutely going to be used. This is a bad idea from any number of matters, but let me give you an idea of what’s in play and what it might be used for, and we’ll go from there. 

So, as you may remember, the USS Tripoli, that’s one of America’s amphibious assault carriers, carries a clutch of F-35 fighter jets, as well as 2000 to 2500 Marines. Relocated from the Philippine Sea and the ceiling through the Indian Ocean. Now, it will probably arrive in the vicinity of the Persian Gulf in the next day or two. 

We also have the USS boxer, which is another EU marine expeditionary unit. That’s basically what the Tripoli is, which has left San Diego. It will not be an area for probably close to three weeks, but the news from yesterday is that the 82nd airborne, which is kind of America’s rapid reaction force, troops that are run by the army, that are mated with permanent transport aircraft that can deploy to anywhere in the world in less than 48 hours. 

They were given the marching orders to move to the Middle East, last night. And we’ll probably. Well, they could be moving right now. You know, all hush hush classified. But when the, orders are given, it’s usually not too long until they’re on their way. Collectively, in three weeks. This means we have about 8000 troops in the region. 

And they’re really heavy hitters. Basically, unless you’re going to move into special operations, the Marines and the airborne are about as good as they get without having armor. And that’s something else that’s important to note. So this is not a traditional ground invasion where we’re driving tanks and using artillery. This would be a relatively light force that punches above its weight for what it is, but is not designed to take on another major force. 

Keep in mind that if the Iranians don’t have another major force, so that should be fine in that regard, they may have a million man army, but it’s apparently designed to shoot civilians rather than swarm over foreign countries. Now, the news is going on and on and on and on about something called Kharg Island. As someone has highlighted Kharg Island 15 years ago, part of me is like, yeah, you finally, but I really doubt that’s the target. 

Or more to the point, I really doubt that that should be the target. Kharg Island is a small facility off the western coast of southwestern Iran. It’s up in the northern Gulf. It doesn’t have a bridge to it. It was built by foreigners, and it has a subsea pipeline that basically carries all Persian Gulf crude to it, because the Persian Gulf Coast is really, really bad to accept tankers. 

It’s just very shallow and muddy. So they have this island out where they can accept tankers. And it is the point for plus of Iran’s oil exports. And what we’ve seen in the war so far is that the United States came in completely unprepared for the idea that something might happen to the Persian Gulf and really didn’t have the hardware or the positioning in place to protect ships in the Gulf, or make sure that the Iranians couldn’t attack ships in the Gulf. 

So everyone’s now focusing on Kharg. And the logic seems to be that Donald Trump wants to make another fucking deal. And the idea is that if the United States occupies Kharg Island, then Trump will have a negotiating card to play against Iran elsewhere. So we will give you Kharg Island back. If you stop attacking places in the Gulf, specifically if you allow the Strait of Hormuz to be open. 

I will tell you bluntly, in anyone who studies, the Middle East will tell you bluntly and, that that will not work, because that will remove Iran’s oil income and then the gloves will really come off. And as we’ve seen, when the Israelis attacked a natural gas processing facility last week, the Iranians had more than enough, weapons left to open up on infrastructure throughout the Gulf. And they did well over $100 billion of damage in a matter of hours. You would probably get something like that. In addition, Kharg Island, is not going to be easy to defend. 

one of the things the United States has been doing is its carriers haven’t even come in the Gulf. One has been off in the Arabian Sea, the other one has been off in the Red sea. 

They’ve been fighting Iran at a distance. If you’re going to put a few thousand troops in Kharg, you’re going to need close in support. And it is within 30 miles of the coast. And the Iranians will hit it with everything they have, because the ability hit several thousand American troops with limited defenses right up and close. Oh, man, they’ve been waiting for a situation like that the entire war. 

It would basically be putting them in the most vulnerable way you could imagine. And now, like I said, anyone who knows anything about this region or oil politics or how defenses work would have told president that this isn’t how things go. But the president isn’t being told anything. The people in the Department of Energy and the DoD who were responsible for studying things like chokepoints and, the Strait of Hormuz specifically, were all fired last year. 

And the same goes for basically any sort of strategic planning or think work. Pete Hegseth, the secretary of Defense, has been going on a crusade in his, Anything that does not actively support the warfighter is being cut out of the Department of the defense, and that removes all education that would allow people to make educated decisions about, say, what you do in war. 

So when I say that this is a Donald Trump plan, this is a Donald Trump plan. He’s no longer allowing information to reach him, with the possible exception of through Dean Cain, who is Joint Chiefs of Staff. And that’s about the only voice of caution he’s get. And so far, he has overruled Cain on really everything of substance. 

So if this is where we’re going, this is going to end in a bit of a debacle. The only other thing that I can think of were 8000 troops that are heavy on the insidious component might be of use, as in the Strait of Hormuz itself, if you put, Marines and airborne in that area, and enable them to do land strikes, rapid and then retreat land strikes up and down the Strait of Hormuz, you can probably limit the ability of Iran to launch attacks on civilian tankers. 

And since the United States doesn’t have the ships, doesn’t have the hardware to do a meaningful convoy system, this might be the next best plan. It’s not a great one, but I would find it much more viable than, say, going after Kharg. That’s my $0.02. Anyway, that’s where we are right now. The Tripoli will arrive within 48 hours, and the 82nd could be there at the same time. 

So if you only feel you need two thirds of these forces, you get going on it right away. If you decide you need the full 8000, you have to wait for the boxer to arrive. And that will not be until the second week of April. Anyway, pieces are moving so that these options are available. Whether they are used, of course, depends upon, what Trump feels, because that’s all that matters in this war.

The Death of the First-Time Home Buyer

A Caucasian couple staring and pointing at a home

Buying your first home is one of those major milestones that your parents and grandparents probably didn’t even think twice about. Now, that milestone is slipping further out of reach for the average American.

US housing prices have trapped those reaching home-buying age in the rent-cycle. Sure, demographic shifts could help, but that relief wouldn’t hit for quite a while. The quickest solution would be ramping up home building, but that hasn’t happened at scale. And demand hasn’t dropped since the boomers are aging in place. Oh, and lending costs are getting higher, too.

It’s the perfect storm to lock out first-time home buyers, and there’s no relief in sight…especially not within this decade.