Mexico has emerged, not simply as America’s top trading partner, but one that is twice as important as China. Reasons range from proximity to economic structure to demographics.
Transcript
Hey everybody. Peter Zeihan here, coming to you from Colorado. It is the 8th of November. And today we’re going to talk about trade structures specifically within North America. The U.S. Census Bureau released its study of American trade patterns last week for 2025. And it shows a significant change in what most people think is the conventional wisdom.
Most people think of China as the dominant trade partner in manufactured products, and there’s definitely a lot of truth to that. I think going back historically, but starting about ten years ago with the first Trump administration, efforts were made politically in the United States, economically in the United States, and certainly within our North American trading partners to change the reality of that. And then about five years ago, we saw more of a structured effort by the Biden administration to slim down the relationship with China economically. And all of that combined has generated a lot of outcomes. And so as of calendar year 2025, which is the last data we have full data for, Mexico has not only surpassed China as our top trading partner, but it’s our top import destination as our top export destination. And China has slipped significantly in the ranks. Now, as with all data, everyone tries to tweak things. And so, for example, the Chinese are trying to ship things to the United States through third countries. With Vietnam probably being the single biggest question there. But the data is real, and it changes the nature of manufacturing in North America and in the United States specifically. So let’s talk about the version of the story that is China versus the version of the story that is Mexico. And then we’ll go into some of the details.
So, first China. The Chinese have never, ever, ever developed a consumer market. Consumer market requires a lot of people in their 20s and 30s and early 40s who have a lot of money, and especially have a lot of children, because when you have kids living in the house, you’re largely focused on caring for them with education and housing and food and all that good stuff. And by the time you hit your 50s, your consumption pulse is largely behind you. Well, the Chinese birthrate collapsed all the way back in the 1980s. And so the best guess is that the American birthrate has been higher than the Chinese birthrate since roughly 1991, which means that at first, when the Chinese did have people in their 20s and 30s and 40s, they were not wealthy. That didn’t happen until just the last decade. And now those people are in their 50s and there’s no kids, so there was never a consumption moment. So the Chinese have always been an export driven system, and they’ve always been a state centered system. And so whenever the Chinese decided that they wanted to go in and try to move into a new type of industry, the government would basically take the savings from the people because it wasn’t being spent on consumption and use it to burn patterns into the Chinese system, so they would forcibly develop infrastructure that they didn’t have in order to target economic sectors that they wanted. And then all of that product had to be exported. Sorry, had a little bit too much coffee this morning. And then when they were ready to move up to the next stage of production, instead of taking that stuff that now they weren’t efficient at and moving it abroad like every other country has ever done, they kept it. They just subsidized it more.
So the Chinese don’t just move up the scale in terms of quality. They hold on to the old stuff even when it’s not economically viable, and they just subsidize it to make it all work. What this means is the Chinese don’t integrate with other countries in terms of industry as much as most countries do. Normally, countries are good at different things because their labor forces have different skill sets and different price points. In China, all of that is made irrelevant by massive subsidies. There’s also a technological element. The Chinese, until recently haven’t developed very many new technologies themselves. They encourage a foreign investor to come in and set up a production facility, and then the people in China that are employed by that facility. The Chinese government’s hire those people to operate a second facility, sometimes across the street, where they basically just strip out all the intellectual property and eventually make a competing system that is subsidized and then drives the original one out of business. And that has been the pattern for foreign investment in China since the beginning. And everyone who moves into China is always surprised when it happens to them, even though it’s happened, thousands of companies just like them in the years before. Anyway, this all adds up to an internal Chinese supply chain system, where as many of the steps as possible are maintained within China, regardless of economic or labor rationale.
That’s not the story of Mexico. Mexico in the early days of globalization in the 50s, 60s and 70s really wanted nothing to do with the United States. And so they didn’t integrate into the international system and really didn’t even industrialize. They were, for lack of a better phrase, fairly backwards until relatively recently. And then when the Cold War ended and the George Herbert Walker Bush administration started negotiations for NAFTA, the Mexicans realized that history had moved on and it was time for them to get over themselves. And so they started talks with the United States on what eventually became the NAFTA accords. And as part of the NAFTA accords, they finally started to industrialize and urbanize. So other countries that did this back in the 50s and the Chinese who started it really in the late 70s, the Mexicans really didn’t get going until the 90s, which meant that this system looked a lot different.
The Mexicans were hard up on the world’s industrial superpower at the time, the U.S., and they had access now to American consumer markets. What they didn’t have as the capital or the technology of the industry. So what we saw is in the northern Mexican states, industrialists started building zones to build things for export, but they lacked a lot of the inputs. And so from the very early days of the Mexican industrial story, it was about integration. Parts were made on both sides of the border, and then they would get shuttled back and forth over and over and over, with each country adding value based on whatever it happened to be. And eventually you get a finished product which would be sent to the United States. But you do that for 30 years and you get two big changes. Number one, those maquiladoras suddenly became industrial parks and became far more valuable in terms of their products and their processing. And number two, enough wealth was generated within Mexico that it’s now $1 trillion consumer economy and is a major consumer of everything the U.S. makes, too. So it’s a bilateral environment with a heavy degree of integration and back and forth, the opposite of what we’ve seen in trade relations with the Chinese, who just try to hoover up every step they can and then dump products on the international market because there’s no local consumption at all.
It’s a much healthier system. It’s much more sustainable. But it brings us to the third point here, which is it feels very, very different from an American point of view. You see, all of this industry is integrated into the American industrial experience has been since the very first day it started back in 1992, which means the United States, in many ways is getting a phenomenal deal here because we don’t pay for the industrial plant, we don’t pay to train the labor, we don’t pay for the local electricity, we don’t pay for the policing to make sure that civil society can function. All of the things that are required at the base to make manufacturing function, those are Mexican costs. So, yes, technically by a very, very, very narrow and deliberately myopic vision, the US may have a trade deficit with Mexico, but that’s only because Mexico has already paid for everything else. Every northern Mexican state trades more with the United States than they do with the rest of Mexico as a whole. They integrate north, not east, west, and certainly not south. For all practical purposes, from an industrial point of view, the northern Mexican states are already parts of the United States, and I dare say something somewhat similar exists in our northern border with Canada as well. Every province in Canada that has an industrial plant at all is more integrated south into the United States than with the rest of Canada. And again, just like with Mexico, they’re paying for everything else and we just get the end result of it.
So moving forward, as globalization breaks down, moving forward, as demographics around the world turn, we have this unique situation in North America where we have three consumption led economies that are integrated to a degree that they’re already a functional industrial space. But the United States hasn’t had to pay for the development of its neighbors as opposed to the, say, the relationship with China, which is I’m oversimplifying here, but product dumping. So if you’re looking for a model that can be perfected, this is the one. And if you’re one of those people who decides that trade relations with Canada or Mexico are a bad thing for the country, then keep in mind that every bit of industry that they have developed over the last 30 to 60 years needs to be redeveloped in the United States in an environment of more expensive electricity, more expensive labor, and more expensive capital. And it needs to be done as quickly as possible. So we’re already dealing with an environment globally where North America has to double the size of its industrial plant if it’s still wants product, if you want to do this without the neighbors, you’re talking about the US having to maybe two and a half times as much. And unlike Mexico and Canada, who paid for their parts, we would have to pay for the whole thing.
So, Americans are very good at doing things the hard way. This might be one of those where maybe we work with what somebody else has already built.








