China is the world’s premier manufacturing superpower. There is no argument there. However, that doesn’t mean China’s industrial dominance is sustainable.
Through scale, technology acquisition (more appropriately called theft), government subsidies, and demographics, China emerged as the world’s manufacturer. But it’s those same forces that are going to bring China down.
Transcript
Hey all, Peter Zeihan here, coming to you from a chilly Colorado. We just had our first freeze on the 16th of October. Today I’m going to talk about why the Chinese are the world’s manufacturing superpower. Because that doesn’t happen by accident.
We have four big factors. The first one, of course, is scale. Contrary to the Communist Party’s teachings. China has not been a unified entity for almost the entirety of its history. It’s more like Europe, where it’s a series of several and sometimes dozens of competing political and economic and military authorities that war with one another. In fact, you could argue quite easily that the North China plane, which is home to two thirds of the Chinese population, is actually the most war torn area throughout history. It’s had 27 major civilizational collapses and literally hundreds of wars. But with the rise of the American order at the end of World War Two, the United States basically told the rest of the world that they can’t invade China for any reason anymore or anyone else, and it left the Chinese in a bit of a bubble to deal with their own domestic issues themselves. And they had a horrific civil war in which Mao Zedong emerged victorious and then proceeded to gut the country twice with the Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward, killing tens of millions of people. But one outcome of that was political unity. So it paid a very, very heavy price, kind of like Americans did the very hardest possible way, but eventually did end up with a single political authority. And you put several hundred million people into the same political authority, and all of a sudden infrastructure can start to link them together. And basically, the story of the Chinese in the late 70s through the late aughts was kind of like what went down in Germany when the Germans unified in 1871, and you got economies of scale for the first time. At the same time, industrial technologies were available and boom, single industrial economy of large scale.
Number two is tech theft. This is one of the Chinese don’t like to talk about as much, but it’s just as important. Two big avenues there. Number one, the Chinese actually do have a bureau whose job is to hack the world and steal technological secrets and then distribute them to their state-owned companies. And that’s obviously something that most other governments don’t really care for. The second one is just foreign investors being stupid. Basically, we’ve seen lots and lots and lots of American, Western, other Asian investors set up production facilities in China to take advantage of the economies of scale, to take advantage of the low labor costs. And then what happens is the Chinese hire a lot of those same workers and build another production facility across the road. And so all these people were double shifts. So they work for the foreign investor, learn what they can, then go across the street and build a copycat. And within a decade, typically the original investor has lost everything. And I’ve always found this hilarious because it’s like everyone knows that it’s happening and everyone knows it’s happening to the people who were there before them, but thinking, you know what? It’s going to be different for me and it never is. So Americans fell for it, Japanese fell for Koreans fell for Germans are the most recent ones to fall for it. And we’ve kind of gotten to the point now that everyone who has something to add has fallen for it. And the Chinese have moved up the value added scale high enough that there’s not a lot of new investment going into that space, because Chinese labor isn’t as cheap as it used to be. In fact, in outward productivity per unit cost per hour that you pay your worker, Chinese worker productivity has actually gone down over the last 25 years. We’ll come back to that. Okay, so that’s tech theft.
Third is subsidization. Sometimes this is direct. Sometimes it’s by shielding the domestic market from any sort of international competition because the Chinese really aren’t all that efficient. But the big one is something called hyper financialization, where the savings of the population is basically not given a lot of places to invest in. And then the state forcibly directs that financial strength directly into the companies, typically via loans that are below the rate of return that you would get on the international market, below the rate of inflation and many times subzero. So basically, you’ve got the entire state apparatus and not just the national level, but the local level, force feeding capital into these industries with loans that arguably will never be paid back. And if you can have access to a bottomless supply of zero or subzero percent loans, you know, of course you’re going to build whatever you want because it doesn’t matter if it’s cost effective. And so the industry just gets bigger and bigger and bigger.
Fourth, and surprisingly, is demographics has been a big part of the success. The Chinese stopped having kids back in the 80s. It looks like from the most recent data that the United States birth rate has been higher than China since roughly 1991. And what that means is today, through the 20 tens and the 2020s, China has lots of people in their 40s and 50s, but no one younger. And so instead of spending your money and your time on kids, you spend it on your career. It also generates a different kind of consumption because you’re buying a car, as opposed to paying for diapers. That generates more economic activity in the short run. Of course, by the time you get your 50s, everything that you need in your life, you already have and you’re just working, working, working. And that generates a massive productivity pulse…once. And we’re in the final years of that working for China, because once you hit 65, that just goes away. Now China being China, I’m sure they will work these people until they die. But for the most part, these are not white collar jobs. And so passed roughly age 62, the human body simply can’t handle the work, and the workforce falls off very, very quickly. And we’re now about at that point. But until now, it means you’ve got this huge workforce that has nothing to do but work. You combine that with the other factors… global manufacturing superpower. Of course, it’s a one shot and we’re now near the end of that.
There’s another angle to all of this. When you produce this much because it’s done artificially. Everything but scale is something that has been introduced to the system to artificially boost manufacturing as a percentage of the economy. You can’t possibly consume what you produce, especially once you start considering the demographic situation. Most consumption is done by people under age 45, and the Chinese just don’t have those people anymore. And that means you have to dump it into the international system. So as long as some version of globalization exists, and as long as political leaders around the world allow market access, the Chinese can hyper produce at home in inefficient industries that are massively subsidized, and they just dump the product everywhere else. And because it’s hyper financialized and they don’t care about sub 0% loans, they can do it at a loss and regularly do. What this also means is that the Chinese economy is atypical compared to everyone before it, not just in terms of its dependance upon the international system, but the Chinese never walk away from a sector that they have dominated. They keep it and they just subsidize it more. So, for example, in the early 2000, the Chinese moved into textiles in a very big way. But Chinese labor costs have gone up by more than a factor of ten there. And the Chinese are wildly, wildly noncompetitive in that sector, now. Normally, it would have been offloaded to a less advanced economy ten years ago. That might have been Vietnam. Today it might be Laos, Cambodia or someplace in Africa. And the Chinese don’t do that. Bangladesh comes to mind. The Chinese don’t do that at all. They keep it all under lockdown. You get local governments to basically fund 20 or 30% of their budget into sectors that are noncompetitive, because from their point of view, it’s the only way to generate revenues and taxes and keep their people employed. If you saw a outflow that was based on labor costs and labor productivity, easily half of the industries in China would pick up and leave. But they are basically not allowed to. Money just keeps getting pumped in. So you get this debt bubble that is conservatively now 400% of GDP just in the corporate space. Before you start considering that the local governments have been borrowing money in order to keep those subsidies going, and the federal government is now starting to get into that activity as well.
So we talk about our debt bubble here in the United States or in Japan, but it’s nothing compared to what is in China. But in China, it is wrapped up in the industrial story. In the United States, it’s largely a government issue. In Japan, it’s largely a pension issue, which means that when this breaks in the United States, it’s a question of how you handle it when you’re the world’s global currency and everyone holds your currency and you have a monetization issue, which is printing currency, which is not great, but it’s an option. In Japan, it’s all domestically held. So you might just be able to wave it away, which they’ve done multiple times in their history. There’s an adjustment there. It’s really certainly not good for the financial sector, but it’s been done. In China, it’s a corporate story. It’s wrapped up with households and the property market and local governments instead of the federal government. There’s no easy way to disentangle it from everything else. And so when that reckoning happens. Wow. And that’s on top of the demographic story. So China. Yes. Industrial superpower. Sustainable. Totally different question.










